Skip to main content

5 of the Best Eggnog K-Cups

Updated for 2018 - See our favorite stuff by clicking "Gear" in the menu above. ↑
Click here to jump straight to the products you are looking for!

With winter just around the corner, many are starting to remember the delicious holiday beverages that begin to swarm the market.

Whether you prefer cinnamon, peppermint or eggnog, there are so many enjoyable flavors.

Those who use K-Cups may begin to wonder if these flavors will also be available for their Keurig machine.

The answer is yes!

In fact, we’re going to take a look into some top eggnog K-Cup options right here!

Carry on, and happy indulging!

T’is The Season

Eggnog is an extremely popular holiday drink, and it can be used in a lot of ways.

Some like it as-is, while others like to make eggnog milkshakes.

Still, some want their eggnog with a touch of coffee.

That’s why there are many eggnog coffees out there that begin to become more popular as fall closes out and winter moves in.

For those who use Keurig machines, there are also K-Cup eggnog options for you!

In the coming weeks, sales for them should really ramp up, so it might be worth grabbing them before the season moves in!

Top Eggnog K-Cups

Below, we’re listing some of the top eggnog K-cup options.

Because it’s still early in the season, there aren’t a lot of these just yet.

However, the one’s we’ve found have some great reviews and a whole lot of delicious flavor!

Green Mountain Spicy Eggnog

Many know Green Mountain as a brand capable of providing delicious brews.

These Spicy Eggnog K-cups are no different!

In this fantastic light roast, you’ll be able to enjoy a creamy flavor with nutmeg and cinnamon.

It’s also an option that is made completely with Arabica coffee, which guarantees it will contain delightful flavor.

On top of that, the brand is certified Fair Trade, so you’ll be able to trust that the brew is fair and sustainable as well as enjoyable.

You can opt for packs of 72, 48 or 24 K-cups so whether you just need a few or want to stock up, you’ll have what you need!

Many customers find this to be a highly delightful option, and many wait for it every year!

It avoids bitterness and navigates the delicious waters without an excess of sugar either.

Consequently, it’s truly the perfect balance for those who are big fans of eggnog!

San Marco Eggnog Cups

For those who like the simple options, these San Marco Eggnog Cups are a great choice.

It’s made to be creamy and complete with the cinnamon-nutmeg flavors you love.

Furthermore, you can choose between 12 and 40-count packages, allowing you to get as much as you need.

Among customers who have tried it out, many have found that the aroma is delicious and the taste is very smooth.

It also provides an interesting flavor that customers appreciate and look forward to during the holidays.

On top of that, the acidity in this option is very balanced, so you won’t need to worry about it ruining the eggnog flavor.

That said, some do tend to favor other eggnog coffee options over the single-serve choices.

In other cases, users can find that it’s lacking in flavor, which leaves them wishing for something more.

Overall, it’s a decent choice for those who want something unique for the winter.

New England Eggnog

The New England Eggnog K-cups are a delightful seasonal favorite that has gotten some great reviews.

This is an option that is made to be creamy, rich and delicious.

Each pack contains 12 pods that you can pop right into your Keurig, allowing it to brew in a matter of moments.

Furthermore, it’s a medium roast, so it will give a bit of a boost without overdoing it for most.

It’s truly a fantastic option for those who are looking for something warm and tasty for cold winter mornings.

Typically, customers who try out this flavor find it to be fantastic.

Even those who tend to be picky about flavored coffees can discover that this option is to their liking.

Keep in mind that it is a seasonal favorite, so it may not always be available.

All the more reason to grab it while you can!

Alternative Options

While K-cup options can sometimes be limited, there are some other choices you can make to still get that eggnog goodness without too much trouble.

We’re going to take a look at some of these options so that you have backup choices if you find that the K-cups you want have been sold out, or are otherwise difficult to find.

Keep in mind that while most of these choices can work with a Keurig, not all of them will.

So if you use a Keurig device primarily, just double check to make sure the option you pick will work for you.

Eggnog Capsules For Other Machines

There are some capsules you can get that are eggnog flavored, but are typically made for other kinds of single-serve machines.

Consequently, this option can help widen the horizons for those with other machines.

One option out there is the Baronet Eggnog flavor, which provides you with 18 capsules.

Just make sure to check to be certain that they’ll work in your single-serve machine before purchasing.

This is a medium roast, similarly to some of the options listed above.

As a result, you’ll be able to get that coffee boost you need without sacrificing flavor or being overwhelmed by caffeine jitters.

Non-Capsule Eggnog Coffee

For those who make use of re-usable coffee filters in their Keurig or other single-serve device, finding eggnog coffee that isn’t already in coffee form is a decent option.

It can be a little easier to find as well as less expensive.

There are plenty of options out there, including the San Marco Eggnog Coffee can easily be found online.

It functions as a decent backup option when you can’t find the K-cups you want.

Furthermore, many customers enjoy this flavor and find it to be easy to brew with.

As a result, it receives some pretty great reviews that are worth checking out!

Eggnog Coffee Recipes

For those who are willing to get a little creative, you can also look for some unique eggnog recipes.

These can include using regular coffee and eggnog syrups or some eggnog itself.

You’ll also be able to get the freedom of deciding whether you want an iced coffee or something hot for those cold days.

If there are other additions you’d like to make, like more cinnamon or other flavors, this is a great option to do that with.

It’s a great backup option for those who like to be able to create drinks exactly to their liking.

A Final Thought

There are a number of great options out there for you eggnog lovers out there!

As we move closer to winter, there are sure to be more popping up all around!

It’s worth trying many of these choices out, and stocking up if you’re a big fan.

After all, they aren’t going to last long!

Many of the eggnog flavors are seasonal, so they will disappear not long before the new year.

It’s also a great time to stock up on any other holiday favorites you may have.

That way you can enjoy them all year long!

Awesome Gear! Amazing Coffee! The Best Prices!

Click here to read the rest of this article.

Does Your Coffee Suck? We Know Why!

Drop your email in the form below and we'll send you a list of the most common reasons your coffee stinks and what to do about it. :)